France is quite familiar with riots- she has a deep culture of protest- beginning at least, with the granddaddy of them all, that of 1789, but not forgetting the violent uprising of February 1848, nor that of March 1871 when, after the complete defeat of the French army by the Germans by March 1871, soldiers of the National Guard seized control of Paris on 18 March for 72 days until 28 May 1871. Their demands included principles such as the separation of church and state, the abolition of child labour, and the rights of women. The Communards killed two French Army generals and refused to accept the authority of the Third Republic. The uprising was savagely put down resulting in some 20 to 30 000 deaths among the communards, with thousands deported to French penal colonies.
After the death of Zyed Benna and Bouna Traoré [1]in October 2005, violent clashes erupted and lasted three weeks, the largest in France since May 1968. Large crowds demonstrated against antisemitism after the killing of Ilan Halimi,[2] a Jew, in February 2006. Over 600 members of forces of order were wounded between 31 March and September 2016, during the protests against proposed labour reforms known as the El Khomri law or Loi travail. The demonstrations associated with the Yellow Vest [Gilet Jaune] movement began in November 2018; they were protests against the rising prices of fuel and crude oil, the high cost of living and economic inequality.
The UEFA Champions league final between Liverpool and Real Madrid scheduled for the evening of 28 May 2022 in the Stade de France in the Paris suburb of Saint-Denis, resulted in chaos as the insufficiently prepared French police tried to control the crowds. After the match (won by Real Madrid, 1-0), organized bands of thugs viciously attacked and robbed both Liverpool and Real Madrid supporters; there is some evidence of sexual assault as well. The Police arrested 68 people, while 238 victims of the violence needed medical attention.
In June 2023 Nahel Merzouk was killed by a policeman during a routine roadside check in Nanterre (approx. 14 kms N.W. of Paris), when he refused to comply with orders. The violence erupted and rapidly spread to Belgium and Switzerland. In France the damage was roughly estimated as a billion Euros.
17 AND 18 OCTOBER 2026.
The provisional balance sheet of the riots in October 2026 in France is: hundreds of demonstrators and teachers wounded, and 997 policemen attacked, more than 8000 in police custody, and more than 40 million euros of damage to property, hundreds of shops and store fronts looted and destroyed, schools only recently renovated were also sacked.
An estimated 550,000 to 800,000 people participated in the protests which were organized by a coalition of Yellow Vest [Gilet Jaune] activists, trade unions, and student groups. Violent fringe elements, described by the government as radical far-left groups and opportunistic criminals, took control of the demonstrations, each group manipulating the crowds for their own political or criminal agenda, sacking public buildings, looting hundreds of businesses, and clashing with police. President Emmanuel Macron condemned the “unbridled violence” in a televised address, acknowledged intelligence failures, and refused Interior Minister Laurent Nuñez’s resignation while ordering a security review.
Preliminary reports suggest that more than 1,500 buildings have been damaged, with some putting the figure at around 3,000. The most reprehensible single incident was the destruction of the 19th-century City Hall in Limoges, where masked protesters set the 143-year-old listed monument ablaze, causing its roof and bell tower to collapse. Eleven days after the fire, the Mayor of Limoges still had not received a word of sympathy or moral support from the French President, Macron, though the Mayor did receive one from the Vice President of the USA, J.D. Vance.
In Marseille, masked groups also besieged the City Hall and a municipal police station, while Lyon’s historic Tourist Office was set ablaze. The Town Hall in Lille was also broken into and vandalized, and the prefect’s residence in Bordeaux was invaded. Paris suffered the heaviest commercial damage, with shattered storefronts and looted businesses concentrated around Place de la République, the Châtelet/Les Halles area, and the Champs-Élysées corridor; targeted establishments included the Galeries Lafayette, Lacoste, SFR, BHV Marais, and luxury boutiques such as Dior, Rolex, Louis Vuitton, and Gucci.
Looting was reported across at least nine cities—Paris, Marseille, Lyon, Bordeaux, Rennes, Strasbourg, Grenoble, Nice, and Limoges—with Carrefour, the large supermarket chain, alone reporting 50 stores damaged and Bordeaux Mayor Thomas Cazenave stating up to 100 stores were looted in his city. Damage was driven by coordinated mobile groups exploiting police overextension, fire propagation in historic timber-roofed structures, and opportunistic looting on the margins of mass demonstrations.
The riots began simply enough in a Lycée in Créteil, a commune in the southeastern suburbs of Paris about 11.7 km (7.3 mi) from the centre of Paris. At Lycée Saint-Exupery, where students, teachers and parents gathered outside the school on Sept. 21 to protest unfilled teaching positions and insufficient resources, understaffed and overcrowded classrooms, and a general lack of maintenance of the school premises, along with heavy work loads for the pupils. The protestors considered that there was far too much selection (where everyone is supposed to succeed; and the baccalaureate has become a human right, no matter what your academic capabilities). And yet spending on each pupil in secondary school has increased by 70% since 1980.
Last year alone, French government spending on education amounted to 5.1% -5.3% of Gross Domestic Product (GDP) placing it slightly above the European Union average of 4.8%. According to World Bank Data of 2022, the total public expenditure on education stood at 5.32% of GDP (around €141.3 billion). But surely the real question has not been posed: how is this money allocated and used? Has its expenditure been properly audited?
Since writing the above I have learnt that my suspicions were totally justified. I read in the 29 October issue of Le Point that a large part of the National Education budget - it will be 32 % in 2027 -is being quietly diverted to fund civil servant pensions. If the budget allocated for education is cut by such an amount, then France can no longer be among the countries that spend the most on education. On the contrary, it risks sliding toward a “Third World Status”.
The level of violence is unprecedented, and shook many law enforcement officers, who, for the first time, feared for their lives. The violence has been defended as legitimate by several politicians, writers, and intellectuals: such as Bally Bagayoko, the left-wing Mayor of Saint-Denis, Francois Begaudeau, a militant writer, and Edouard Louis, writer and disciple of Pierre Bourdieu and Annie Ernaux. But what are the reactions of the politicians in general? While Macron mouths empty slogans about how “inadmissible” all the violence was, some Conservative politicians had more coherent and practical suggestions. For example, Senator David Marguerite of the Conservative Party- Les Republicains- suggested that there should be more severe sanctions for participation in undeclared or forbidden demonstrations.
There is also some movement towards creating a law whereby the looters are held responsible and have to pay for the damaged caused. David Marguerite says the French public is fed up with the ease with which those hauled up before judges nonetheless walk free. It is an asymmetric war; the hands of the law enforcement officers are tied, and every move of the latter is carefully monitored and scrutinized. We need more confidence in our law enforcement officials, who should be treated with respect as guardians of our security and safety, instead of being treated with suspicion, hatred and mistrust.
Both the US President Donald Trump and his Vice President J.D. Vance attribute the violence to too lax policies of immigration. The President and Vice President are not entirely wrong. Once the riots started, it was joined by Muslim youths-scores of unassimilated Muslims who have no interest in preserving the culture of their hosts, to a country in which they feel they do not belong. For decades French intellectuals and political philosophers have drummed into the empty minds of these Muslims that the France and the West generally is evil, and the source of all evil, as Susan Sontag once put it.[3] Why would, in that case, anyone want to assimilate into a sinking ship or a den of iniquity?
The most sober contemporary philosopher is Pascal Bruckner who has, for the last twenty years, tried to undo the damage caused by Sartre, Foucault, Edward Said, and their epigones. He lives in the centre of Paris and has given us his vivid eyewitness testimony of the riots, which was published in Le Figaro, and parts of which I have translated here in a very free manner:
“It is a luxury boutique located at the corner of Rue des Filles-du-Calvaire and Rue de Turenne. Around 6:58 p.m. on October 17, a group of hooded individuals began attacking the expansive, illuminated storefront—using nothing but concrete blocks, manhole covers, fire extinguishers, and crowbars. It was a laborious process, but the energy and vigor of the assailants eventually caused the glass to spiderweb, crack, and buckle. Local residents called the police… who acknowledged the call but never showed up. From noon until midnight, in this neighborhood near République—right in the heart of Paris—not a single uniform was to be seen. Not one!!! Finally, a breach was opened in the display window; the assailants rushed inside—careful to avoid cutting themselves on the glass—and helped themselves to the merchandise. They were swift, coordinated, and professional. A true commando-style operation.
“They emerge with shirts, suits, bags, and expensive shoes: a tidy haul. The whole thing lasted about half an hour. Throughout the evening, men can be seen carrying packages in their arms: their free “purchases” of the day. A little later, in front of the same store, two figures, also camouflaged, reappear, each carrying a full bag. A man watching the shop calls out to them and asks if they aren’t ashamed of stealing. Two teenagers: “Sir, sir, please, we didn’t get anything, we’re the last ones...” Finally, they compromise and leave with only one bag.”
Notice how the looters are perfectly aware of the delights of owning high end luxury goods, everything from shoes to handbags. Their envy and resentments at not having the means of legitimately purchasing them are, of course, exploited by the Left in general, not just the extremists. They are taught that the West got rich by plundering their colonies, and using slave-labour, both claims are false as I have recently argued in “Churchill’s Secular Creed…” Consequently the looters are encouraged to believe that they have every right to those luxury goods- they do not need, they are told, to justify their looting and delinquency.
Bruckner continues: “Two worlds collide. It all started around noon, with the first mortars and tear gas grenades. These are good-natured processions, mostly very young, shouting: “Bourgeois, bourgeois, don’t look at us, join us!” So proud to be taking to the streets. The first tourists are arriving, the terraces are full, the weather is beautiful. Two worlds collide: that of the visitors to this affluent neighborhood, a favorite spot for American, Italian, and Chinese shoppers, and that of the protesters, chanting a variety of slogans. But behind these processions, where Palestinian flags are waving, come older individuals, hooded and masked, dressed all in black. They clearly have other concerns on their minds than the high school reforms or the Parcoursup[4]university admissions platform. The clashes began in the Place de la République, where the crowd enthusiastically chants “We are all children of Gaza.” For hours, explosions ring out before the incredulous eyes of passersby.”
No, you are not the children of Gaza.[5] At best you are the result of an alliance of the Bourgeois and Cultural Left, steeped in Third-Worldism, self-loathing, and hatred of Israel- and, at the other extreme, a suburban milieu shaped by identity-based political Islam, along with a hatred of the West and of the Jews. You couldn’t care less about the children of Gaza, any more than you care about the children of Ukraine or of the Sudan. You couldn’t care less about them, just as you couldn’t have cared less back then about the children of Bucha (Ukraine) massacred by the Russians in 2022, or the children in Iran in 2026, mowed down by their own government. You are the spoiled children of a country that is saddling its great-grandchildren with debt just to prop up one of the most redistributive social systems in the world. “Free Palestine”? No, no, no !!! The looters prefer Free Gucci, Free Rolex, Free Louis Vuitton, Free Reebok, and anything else they can lay their hands on, since it’s all Free! And in any case, what on earth has Palestine got to do with the demands of the high-school pupils for better conditions in their schools: more teachers, more funds? In other words, once again, these riots have been taken over by the LFI [La France Insoumise: France Unbowed, Far Left Party founded in 2016 by Jean-Luc Mélenchon]. Mélenchon has very expertly manoeuvred and manipulated the riots in order to keep up the pressure on Macron’s government, with an eye to the presidential election in 2027. At the demonstrations in Paris at the Place de la République, Mélenchon was in his element addressing the crowd. The battle for the Presidency will first play out on the streets.
Mélenchon has allied himself with various anti-Western leftist groups and Muslim organisations, his core electorate, to instrumentalise and politise what were, after all, at the beginning, minor school protests, turning them into violent riots and organised looting to suit and propagate his revolutionary political agenda. Mélenchon is intimidating the French and preparing the French for the revolution that he hopes to bring about. Though it is possible that Marine Le Pen will defeat Mélenchon in the elections, he will not accept it and bring out his supporters into the streets. If he does not win at the Ballot Box, he will make sure the French will not sleep tranquilly.
Trump and Vance are only partly correct since the riots were equally driven by White French youth and students, who have also imbibed the hatred of the West, of their own culture. Do not be surprised if your White children, even those who are college-educated and intelligent, and with a decent job, come home one day and suddenly announce at the dinner table that they wish to give half their salaries away in order to make amends for their own, unfair White Privilege.
Bruckner again: “By mid-afternoon, the rioters arrive in droves. Shops close one after another, as do cafés. Le Progrès, on the corner of Rue de Bretagne, barricades itself; waiters, armed with truncheons, remain inside, ready to clash with the protesters. By 6:00 p.m., the scene is apocalyptic: bands of youths, laughing and joking, recount their exploits, reenact skirmishes with the police, and scout for new targets. What is most striking is the high spirits of the participants, who shout, “Wallah, Wallah!” They are jubilant—they have occupied a terrorized capital, becoming masters of an opulent, indifferent city that taunts them with its riches. Paris, an open city. The air is unbreathable, thick with the stench of fire and tear gas.
“On Boulevard du Temple, bicycles are set ablaze; some individuals manage to reach the upper floors of buildings, pounding on the doors of terrified residents. The Kitsuné boutique is looted, and the Salomon store on Rue Vieille-du-Temple is likewise ransacked. Jewelry stores, shoe shops, and luxury clothing boutiques are the primary targets. Only the Acacia bookstore, near République, remains untouched—a fact that is all the more damning: literature has become so utterly irrelevant to everyone that no one even bothers to attack a place of culture. Everywhere, the same slogan is scrawled on walls and storefronts: “Bismillah, it is the darkness“—a phrase whose final part resonates most: a promise of a bleak era defined by looting, destruction, and violence. On television, Laurent Nuñez [Minister of the Interior] clearly proud of his handling of the situation, vehemently rejects any suggestion of a state of emergency.”
One can easily identify the culture of the looters by their cries of “Wallah, Wallah”, and perhaps, if authentic, “Bismillah, [In Arabic: “in the name of God”] it is the darkness”. Perhaps a more unequivocal example would be the fact that when the mob looted the butchers, they only took beef, lamb, and chicken, leaving untouched the pork and other non-halal meat, pates, and other prepared meals. Heavens! Looters with principles it seems. Albeit, Islamic ones. In another telling example, looters in Marseille left untouched a shop owned by a Muslim, while sacking, looting, and destroying all the others in the vicinity.
Behind all the riots lies the usual Islamo-leftist alliance, which dates at least from Jean-Paul Sartre’s endorsement, in his preface to Frantz Fanon’s The Wretched of the Earth, of Fanon’s legitimation of violence against the White Man. Fanon was a bitter fanatic who argued that violence against the White man was fully justified. Sartre’s approval of anti-white violence was followed by Michel Foucault’s embrace of Khomeini’s Islamic theocracy. Both the Left and Muslims hate the West, and her achievements. Mélenchon is heir to a long tradition of Islamo-leftism, an alliance evident in the recent riots.
The riots are the consequence of an abandonment of all responsibility as Bruckner concludes his eye-witness account. “It stems from a tolerance for internal decay and for the eruptions of violence in the suburbs—violence often attributed to “racism” or postcolonial guilt—as well as a growing habituation to acts of incivility, which are excused by pointing to capitalism or “police brutality.” What happened last Saturday will inevitably happen again; it is a mere foretaste of the chaos to come. This will continue unless our authorities finally recognize security as the foremost human right and act accordingly, for instance, by banning future demonstrations. Failing this, the gleeful thugs of October 17th will seem like harmless extras compared to those who will follow: criminal gangs steered by the far-left, intent on bringing our country to its knees. A silent coup d’état.”
Macron said during a campaign speech in 2017, “Il n’y a pas une culture française. Il y a une culture en France et elle est diverse” which can be translated as : “There is no such thing as French culture. There is a culture in France, and it is diverse.” Later in the same speech, Macron went on to clarify what he meant: “La culture française est un fleuve alimenté par des affluents multiples”(”French culture is a river fed by multiple tributaries”). His quote was wildly misinterpreted. But if Macron is putting forward an argument for multiculturalism, he is still woefully misguided. If French culture is not better at anything one cannot ask anyone to adopt it. Multiculturalism has failed as Angela Merkel, the then German Chancellor said in 2010. In fact, she was even more forthright: she said Germans had failed “utterly” in building a multicultural society. Immigrants need to do more to integrate into German society, beginning, at least, by learning German. Was Macron adumbrating a philosophy of cultural relativism? But cultural relativism, while seeming to be cosmopolitan and humble is in fact based on the pious and false assumption that all cultures are equal. They are not?
Islam is anything but relativist, and all North African Muslims regard Islam as superior- it is the final word, it is the truth from God Himself. Islam is the answer to all the questions in life, it is a totalitarian construct. Muslims consider the Sharia, Islamic Law, far superior to any Western values such as the equality of men and women before the Law. While Muslims are convinced of their own superiority, and are fighting to impose Sharia on the West, Western intellectuals have ceased to believe in anything, and spend their time groveling in the mud, apologizing for their own very existence, and of the West itself (Susan Sontag comes to mind again). Who is likely to win this unequal contest? It will not lead to coexistence. It will lead to the annihilation of Western values and the West. It will lead to the triumph of Islam. I am often asked what should be done to combat Islam. We could begin by getting rid of Sharia courts in the West, by banning Islamic practices that go against the law, against the U.S. Constitution, such as female genital mutilation, by simply standing up proudly for our own values and achievements.
In a public debate with Tariq Ramadan in London on October 9, 2007, I was given eight minutes to argue for the superiority of Western values. This was a part of my defense of the West (the full eight minutes form the Prologue to my book “Why the West is Best”[6]): “The whole edifice of modern science is one of Western man’s greatest gifts to the world.6 The West is responsible for almost every major scientific discovery of the last five hundred years, from heliocentrism and the telescope, to electricity, to computers…
“The West has given the world the symphony and the novel. A culture that engendered the spiritual creations of Mozart and Beethoven, Wagner and Schubert, of Raphael and Michelangelo, Leonardo da Vinci and Rembrandt does not need lessons in spirituality from societies whose vision of heaven resembles a cosmic brothel stocked with virgins for men’s pleasure.
“The West does not need lectures on the superior virtue of societies where women are kept in subjection, endure genital mutilation, are married off against their will at the age of nine, have acid thrown in their faces or are stoned to death for alleged adultery, or where human rights are denied to those regarded as belonging to lower castes. The West does not need sanctimonious homilies from societies that cannot provide clean drinking water or sewage systems for their populations, that cannot educate their citizens but leave 40 to 50 percent of them illiterate, that make no provision for the handicapped, that have no sense of the common good or civic responsibility, that are riddled with corruption.”
THE DEMONSTRATIONS OF NOVEMBER 5.
A preliminary estimate of the number of demonstrators in all France on 5 November was 600,000. That is greater than the 550,000 of 17 October, and far greater than the paltry 256,000 of 6 October. The focus of the demands of the demonstrators was an increase in salaries and purchasing power. The Secretary General of the powerful trade union, CGT [
Some 70000 police and gendarmes remained vigilant until nightfall. In Lyon some forty people were injured including 34 law enforcement officers. Many shop fronts were destroyed. At Lycée Léonard-de-Vinci in Roubaix [NWFrance], two people were interrogated for throwing mortars, while a police source indicated that at Valenciennes in NW France, the son of an imam was detected among the gatherings. From the early hours of the day, police officers from the Prefecture of Police fanned out across train stations and its inner suburbs.
It is significant that only 2.2% of the Lycées were blockaded (that is, 81 high schools out of a total of 3700), though the High School Student Union, which is close to the LFI of Mélenchon, claimed that 1000 lycées were on strike. But as one unionist teacher pointed out, to demonstrate is one thing, and to blockade is another. Public opinion is shifting and the movement seems to be winding down, though there remain violent elements within it.
The Government has already pledged reform of the hated Parcoursup (the official national web platform used to manage access to higher education in France. Created in 2018 to replace the former “APB” (Admission Post-Bac) system, it centralizes the application process for almost all post-secondary (post-baccalaureate) study programs.), to lower the price of diesel, and raise the minimum wage. Without any money, nor a majority in parliament, the Government is limited in what it can offer. It does not have any time in front of it, either. The country is ailing but the silent majority want an end to the disorder. It is however a hostage to those, like La France Insoumise, of Mélenchon, who want to slide the country further into the abyss. Macron had promised to bring all French people together. Instead he has abandoned them to the engineers of the chaos.
Meanwhile, more demonstrations are promised in the weeks ahead….
[1] The deaths of Zyed Benna and Bouna Traoré occurred on October 27, 2005, in Clichy-sous-Bois, when two teenagers were electrocuted inside an electrical substation they had entered to escape a police check.
[2] The murder of Ilan Halimi was the kidnapping, torture, and murder of a young Frenchman of Moroccan Jewish ancestry in France in 2006. Halimi was held and tortured for three weeks by many North African Muslims.
[3] Winter issue of Partisan Review, 1967.
[4] Parcoursup is the official national web platform used to manage access to higher education in France. Created in 2018 to replace the former “APB” (Admission Post-Bac) system, it centralizes the application process for almost all post-secondary (post-baccalaureate) study programs.
[5] I am loosely paraphrasing Sophia Aram in the journal Le Point (22 October 2026 no 2830).
[6] Ibn Warraq, Why the West is Best. A Muslim Apostate’s Defense of Liberal Democracy, New York: Encounter Books, 2011.




Heirs of Cain
You are the heirs of Cain
because you kill your brothers
for the same reasons:
because another’s offering rose sweeter,
because you were not chosen first,
because scarcity is easier to believe than enough,
because wounded pride demands an altar,
because you fear another’s blessing is your theft,
because the land is small and your hunger holy,
because a border is cheaper than a brother,
because silence is lighter than a knock,
because a headline can make a stranger
into a rightful enemy.
The mark is not monstrous.
It is the ordinary face you wear
when you call your envy justice,
You fear security,
You need to be first
a birthright.
Still the ground opens its mouth.
Still you ask, Am I my brother’s keeper?
Still you kill for what Cain killed for:
the unbearable sight of someone else
being loved.
France is getting what it deserves.