157 Comments
User's avatar
Neil M's avatar

How many on the Left I wonder, are, in large part, ignorant of, and completely incurious about, Islam? Muslims are, in the West, a minority. As such, 'minority status' is enough for the Left, especially when a "phobia" can be attached to the minority. For younger 'passionate' Leftists maybe it's this simple? They don't need / want to know / think any more about it.

Rory Bowman's avatar

Most self-identified "leftists" are contemptuous of religion and look down on it as quaint and vaguely beneficent, without taking it seriously or learning much about it. They also see themselves as "multicultural" without much cultural literacy, and "educated" without much geography or history. It is maddening, especially when trying to engage them on specifics. They are culturally puritanical and protestants with no knowledge of where either of those words came from, very fond of drama triangles and simplistic fairy tales.

John Coombes's avatar

Their foundation is based on the atheist nature bred by the 4 horsemen of the latter 19th century.

Marx, Darwin, Nietzsche and Freud. Undermined the Judeo-Christian ethos of what made the West the greatest Civilisation in human history. Their disciples are actively and publicly determined to destroy all that is good in the midst of evil. And social media fake news does the work for the.

As a Canadian Serge le Clerq once told his government what was causing the rapid increase in violence, sexual excess and drug abuse amongst the youth. ‘You have expelled Jesus Christ from the public square. What kind of mentor steps into his place?’

ACollectionofSoulsandScenes's avatar

There is no such thing as Judeo- Christian, it’s an oxymoron

Rory Bowman's avatar

Christianity relies upon Judaism for its grounding, and so is Judeo-Christian historically and doctrinally, much as Buddhism emerges from previous Indian religions. This strongly contrasts with Islam, where Mohammed claims to speak as "the final prophet" of the Jewish god but abrogates the authority of Jews and Christians alike, drawing almost nothing but Jewish dietary restrictions from either.

John Coombes's avatar

OK. So is Jesus a Jew or a Gentile? Read the account of Jesus and the Samaritan woman. Salvation is of the Jews Luke 19:9. And maybe spend some time in Roman's 9-11. We non-Jews are grafted in, we are not a separate ‘tree’ as it were.

Because at the end of it every Christian, Gentile or Jew, will be residents of the New Jerusalem with a Saviour who was born, died, resurrected and ascended as a Jew. That is Yahweh's Way.

Be blessed in any case.

Mou aressi's avatar

There’s no left Islam alliance. The premise is wrong. The left is fighting for Palestinian rights.

why should Palestinian Arabs suffer for what the Germans did to the Jews?? That’s the fundamental issue and the question you cannot answer.

Peter Hemmingson's avatar

THE ROOTS OF ISLAMIC ANTISEMITISM

Let’s explore the origins of Muslim Arab anti-Semitism and its impact on the Israeli-Palestinian Arab conflict.

The two-state DELUSION that has mesmerised Western leftards for decades is a mirage.

Naive liberal Jews who think just one more concession will bring about peaceful co-existence with their Muslim Arab neighbours are similarly deluded.

It's often claimed that Israel is provoked by the mere existence of Palestinian Arabs and seeks their genocidal destruction. Nice bait-and-switch.

In reality, it is Arab Islamists, driven by an intractable animosity towards Jews, who seek their complete eradication.

This hostility is rooted in longstanding anti-Semitism within Islamic tradition, predating the establishment of Jewish Israel by many centuries. This pervades the Islamic Ummah wherever Muslims are to be found in the world.

Muslim anti-Semitism originated in the 7th century, with Muhammad. Islamic scripture, including the Koran and Hadith, describes the Jewish community of Yathrib (now Medina) repeatedly refusing to convert to Islam when asked to, and mocking Muhammad’s claim to be God’s final prophet in the Jewish and Christian tradition.

Muhammad then cursed the Jews, calling them “the offspring of apes and pigs” and condemning them in this world and the next.

Islamic teaching instructs Muslims to love what Allah loves and hate what Allah hates. Allah loves Muslims and hates disbelievers.

The Jews—who rejected Islam and mocked Muhammad—are regarded as Islam’s most persistent enemy. This is underscored by Koran 5:82: “You will find the most vehement of the people in hostility to the believers to be the Jews.”

Muslim Jew-hatred is reflected in various Hadith, such as the one that is part of the Hamas Charter: “The Day of Judgement will not come until Muslims fight the Jews, when the Jews will hide behind stones and trees. The stones and trees will say ‘O Muslim, there is a Jew behind me, come and slaughter him.’”

Islamic anti-Semitism has intensified in modern times. During the 1930s and 40s, Nazi propaganda exacerbated Muslim Arab eliminationism..

Haj Amin al-Husseini, the Grand Mufti of Jerusalem, collaborated closely with the Nazis during World War II. Al-Husseini met with Hitler and other Nazi leaders, endorsed their anti-Semitic views, promoted Nazi propaganda claims, and encouraged Arab Islamists to back the Nazi war effort.

Through this connection, Adolf Hitler’s book, Mein Kampf, was translated into Arabic, and is to this day widely read and revered in the Islamic world for its anti-Jewish content.

Pakistan’s famed Ulema scholar, Sheikh Maulana Mawdudi has expressed admiration for “the ingenious and mighty leadership of Adolf Hitler and his comrades.”

Hezbollah leader Hasan Nasrullah has echoed Nazi racial sentiments, stating: “If we searched the entire world for a person more cowardly, despicable, weak and feeble in psyche, mind, ideology and religion, we would not find anyone like the Jew.”

Sermonising against Israel on Egypt's Al-Rahma TV in October 2009, Egyptian cleric Hazem Shuman stated: “It has been proven that the Jews are like a cancer – if they are not removed from the body of the [Islamic] nation, they will kill the entire nation.”

Another key factor is the belief that once a place has been ruled by Islam, it remains the rightful property of Muslims forever.

Koran 2:191: “Kill them wherever you come upon them and drive them out of the places from which they have driven you out.”

Israel, part of the Middle East under Ottoman Turkish Muslim control for centuries after the fall of the Byzantine Empire—with a brief interlude of Crusader occupation—is thus viewed by Muslim Arabs (and indeed the entire Islamic Ummah) as Islamic land that must be reclaimed.

Ahmad Bahr, Deputy Speaker of the Hamas Parliament, stated on Al-Aqsa TV in 2012: “If the enemy sets foot on a single square inch of Islamic land, Jihad becomes an individual duty, incumbent on every Muslim, male or female.”

Speaking at a Gaza public rally in 2012, Hamas leader Khaled Mashaal proclaimed: “Since Palestine is ours, and it is the land of the Arabs and Islam, it is unthinkable that we would recognise the legitimacy of the Israeli occupation of it ... Let me emphasise that we adhere to this fundameintal principle: We do not recognize Israel … The Palestinian resistance will crush it and sweep it away, be it Allah’s will.”

Such statements convey a brief sample of Islamic anti-Semitism and eliminationism, an absolute denial of the right of the Jews to a homeland of their own, on lands that traditionally belonged to the Jewish people for over two millennia before the advent of Muhammad.

The Palestinian Arabs could have had their own state in 1948 when the UN voted to partition part of the former British Mandate of Palestine into a state for the Palestinian Arabs and a state for the Jews, but chose instead to try and wipe out the Jews altogether.

Despite getting flogged by the Israelis in this—and every subsequent conflict they have provoked—Muslim Arabs have never resiled from that position. Many Arab maps of the Middle East do not even show Israel.

The Palestinian Arabs have made it very clear that if they have to live next door to a Jewish state, they are not interested in another Arab state on part of the lands of the former Ottoman Empire.

The Arab Islamist pack snarl “From the River to the Sea, Palestine will be free” actually means “From the River [Jordan] to the [Mediterranean] Sea, Palestine will be Jew-free.”

Given this historical and ideological backdrop, we can see that from the Arab Islamist perspective, any cessation of hostilities will always be temporary and tactical.

The precedent comes from the Treaty of al-Hudaybiyyah (628 AD), when Muhammad, being militarily weaker than the Quraysh, signed a ten-year peace treaty with the Meccans.

Once his forces grew stronger, Muhammad trumped up an excuse to claim the treaty had been broken, using this as justification to march on and conquer Mecca.

In classical Islamic jurisprudence, this episode underpins the doctrine that a truce [hudna] with unbelievers may be concluded only when Muslims are too weak to continue jihad successfully.

It must not exceed ten years, after which hostilities should resume if the balance of power allows.

Jurists like Ibn Taymiyyah and al-Mawardi explicitly codified this principle: truces are permissible only for tactical reasons and only temporarily, until conditions favour renewed jihad.

This means any peace treaty with non-Muslims is provisional and strategic, never permanent.


The invocation “Remember Hudaybiyyah” among Palestinian Arab leaders when speaking of ceasefires or peace treaties with Israel directly alludes to this very logic — outward accommodation masking a long-term strategic objective.

Lasting peace is impossible with deceitful people who harbor such deep-seated, longstanding religious-based hatred and enmity.

ENDS

Maureen Mehlman's avatar

The two state solution was the creation of Jordan at the same time Israel was created. Many muslims chose not to move to Jordan. When they thought they would be better off migrating away(given the extreme attacks Israel was suffering from all neighboring Muslim countries), no other Muslim nation would give them refuge, thus creating the so called palestinian refugees. Along comes Yassir Arafat in the 60's and starts a counter revolutionary group he calls the PLO.

THE WHOLE THING WAS A SETUP TO HAVE THESE IMAGINARY REFUGEES. ISRAEL DIDNT THROW THEM OUT. NO ONE ELSE WOULD TAKE THEM.

Then the terror attacks started to come from within and the embattled new nation of Israel has to find a way to

Maureen Mehlman's avatar

Wow. Nailed it. Impressive. I just wish any of these brainwashed pinheads would take any time to research anything. But they're too busy scrolling.....

John Coombes's avatar

Extremely well said.Thanks for the comprehensive Insight. At last somebody is actually quoting the Koran's violent and hateful rhetoric. Diametrically opposed to Jesus' teaching.

Maureen Mehlman's avatar

Are you serious? The left doesn't even know what a Palestinian is. Clearly you dont. If you are talking about Gazan Muslims then perhaps you've been too busy protesting ir scrolling TikTok or Instagram to notice that the Gazan ppl (who are not Palestinian any more than The Israelis) elected Hamas to lead them who launched an unimaginably brutal attack upon the Israeli ppl taking 250 or so hostages. All they had to do was return the hostages to stop the war on Gaza but their evil Hamas overlords refused because they knew the Israelis would fight hard which would cause civilian deaths in Gaza, a heavily occupied urban strip of land. While the Israelis did try to mitigate excess collateral damage, the Hamas leadership made it almost impossible. They stole relief supplies intended for the trapped citizenry, refused to let civilians seek shelter from bombing and even made the public statement that all the casualties were worth it to get empathy from the liberal factions across the western world. The whole thing was about a massive PR stunt and an excuse to kill, rape and torture Israeli Jews. They dont even value the lives of their own ppl enough to protect them.

There are no "Palestinians" in part because there is no nation of Palestine. There was never a nation called Palestine. The Romans renamed Judea,( the entire area of what is now Yemen, Iraq, Syria, Qatar, Israel, Jordan and the UAE) Palestine. That rendered all the inhabitants of Judea "palestinian".

After the sacking of Jerusalem by the Romans in 70 AD, most Hebrews left and traveled northward toward eastern and central Europe. That was called the diaspora. A few sephardic hebrews remained along with sephardic Arabs and a growing Christian community. Fast forward 600 yrs and along comes Mohammed, the self appointed prophet who seizes the opportunity to unite the disenfranchised Arab tribes by unifying them through his writings. He is charismatic, intelligent and very persuasive. He basically rewrote the hebrew scriptures giving the inheritance of Isaac and Jacob unto the descendants of Ishmael and Esau. They set about bringing all other inhabitants of the vast area of Judea, now recorded as Palestine on European maps, under the rule of Islam. Thousands are forced to convert, increasing Mohammed's army. Near the end of his life, Mohammed finds he is satisfied with the power he's accumulated and then writes that Christians and Jews are to be given the choice to convert as they are ppl of the "book". They are to pay an extra tax if choosing not to convert. Once Mohammed passes away the infighting for controlling powers over the muslim community start. Some factions decide to disregard Mohammed's change of heart and do not acknowledge any right to choose and return to coercion tactics. As with any expanded group of humans, wealth and power inspire treachery. They find themselves battling one another until Attila the Hun starts his own reign of terror and clashes with north and eastern factions. Over time things settle and the Holy Roman Empire is now another contender. Islamic forces have pushed into parts of Italy and most of the Spanish peninsula. To this day Spain looks more like Istanbul in architecture than most of the rest of Europe.

I'm sure I've oversimplified this history lesson and left important things out but the youth in the western world have been undereducated about this and are easily manipulated by relentless propaganda, amplified greatly by a very leftist media across the entirety of western civilization.

The big point here is that you're deceived. Research more and get a real education.

Neil M's avatar

Take a look at the UK Green Party to see the alliance in action and in all its contradictions.

Mou aressi's avatar

Are you telling me that the UK green party is advocating something more than Palestinian rights and if so, what is it?

Peter Hemmingson's avatar

THE ROOTS OF ISLAMIC ANTISEMITISM

Let’s explore the origins of Muslim Arab anti-Semitism and its impact on the Israeli-Palestinian Arab conflict.

The two-state DELUSION that has mesmerised Western leftards for decades is a mirage.

Naive liberal Jews who think just one more concession will bring about peaceful co-existence with their Muslim Arab neighbours are similarly deluded.

It's often claimed that Israel is provoked by the mere existence of Palestinian Arabs and seeks their genocidal destruction. Nice bait-and-switch.

In reality, it is Arab Islamists, driven by an intractable animosity towards Jews, who seek their complete eradication.

This hostility is rooted in longstanding anti-Semitism within Islamic tradition, predating the establishment of Jewish Israel by many centuries. This pervades the Islamic Ummah wherever Muslims are to be found in the world.

Muslim anti-Semitism originated in the 7th century, with Muhammad. Islamic scripture, including the Koran and Hadith, describes the Jewish community of Yathrib (now Medina) repeatedly refusing to convert to Islam when asked to, and mocking Muhammad’s claim to be God’s final prophet in the Jewish and Christian tradition.

Muhammad then cursed the Jews, calling them “the offspring of apes and pigs” and condemning them in this world and the next.

Islamic teaching instructs Muslims to love what Allah loves and hate what Allah hates. Allah loves Muslims and hates disbelievers.

The Jews—who rejected Islam and mocked Muhammad—are regarded as Islam’s most persistent enemy. This is underscored by Koran 5:82: “You will find the most vehement of the people in hostility to the believers to be the Jews.”

Muslim Jew-hatred is reflected in various Hadith, such as the one that is part of the Hamas Charter: “The Day of Judgement will not come until Muslims fight the Jews, when the Jews will hide behind stones and trees. The stones and trees will say ‘O Muslim, there is a Jew behind me, come and slaughter him.’”

Islamic anti-Semitism has intensified in modern times. During the 1930s and 40s, Nazi propaganda exacerbated Muslim Arab eliminationism..

Haj Amin al-Husseini, the Grand Mufti of Jerusalem, collaborated closely with the Nazis during World War II. Al-Husseini met with Hitler and other Nazi leaders, endorsed their anti-Semitic views, promoted Nazi propaganda claims, and encouraged Arab Islamists to back the Nazi war effort.

Through this connection, Adolf Hitler’s book, Mein Kampf, was translated into Arabic, and is to this day widely read and revered in the Islamic world for its anti-Jewish content.

Pakistan’s famed Ulema scholar, Sheikh Maulana Mawdudi has expressed admiration for “the ingenious and mighty leadership of Adolf Hitler and his comrades.”

Hezbollah leader Hasan Nasrullah has echoed Nazi racial sentiments, stating: “If we searched the entire world for a person more cowardly, despicable, weak and feeble in psyche, mind, ideology and religion, we would not find anyone like the Jew.”

Sermonising against Israel on Egypt's Al-Rahma TV in October 2009, Egyptian cleric Hazem Shuman stated: “It has been proven that the Jews are like a cancer – if they are not removed from the body of the [Islamic] nation, they will kill the entire nation.”

Another key factor is the belief that once a place has been ruled by Islam, it remains the rightful property of Muslims forever.

Koran 2:191: “Kill them wherever you come upon them and drive them out of the places from which they have driven you out.”

Israel, part of the Middle East under Ottoman Turkish Muslim control for centuries after the fall of the Byzantine Empire—with a brief interlude of Crusader occupation—is thus viewed by Muslim Arabs (and indeed the entire Islamic Ummah) as Islamic land that must be reclaimed.

Ahmad Bahr, Deputy Speaker of the Hamas Parliament, stated on Al-Aqsa TV in 2012: “If the enemy sets foot on a single square inch of Islamic land, Jihad becomes an individual duty, incumbent on every Muslim, male or female.”

Speaking at a Gaza public rally in 2012, Hamas leader Khaled Mashaal proclaimed: “Since Palestine is ours, and it is the land of the Arabs and Islam, it is unthinkable that we would recognise the legitimacy of the Israeli occupation of it ... Let me emphasise that we adhere to this fundameintal principle: We do not recognize Israel … The Palestinian resistance will crush it and sweep it away, be it Allah’s will.”

Such statements convey a brief sample of Islamic anti-Semitism and eliminationism, an absolute denial of the right of the Jews to a homeland of their own, on lands that traditionally belonged to the Jewish people for over two millennia before the advent of Muhammad.

The Palestinian Arabs could have had their own state in 1948 when the UN voted to partition part of the former British Mandate of Palestine into a state for the Palestinian Arabs and a state for the Jews, but chose instead to try and wipe out the Jews altogether.

Despite getting flogged by the Israelis in this—and every subsequent conflict they have provoked—Muslim Arabs have never resiled from that position. Many Arab maps of the Middle East do not even show Israel.

The Palestinian Arabs have made it very clear that if they have to live next door to a Jewish state, they are not interested in another Arab state on part of the lands of the former Ottoman Empire.

The Arab Islamist pack snarl “From the River to the Sea, Palestine will be free” actually means “From the River [Jordan] to the [Mediterranean] Sea, Palestine will be Jew-free.”

Given this historical and ideological backdrop, we can see that from the Arab Islamist perspective, any cessation of hostilities will always be temporary and tactical.

The precedent comes from the Treaty of al-Hudaybiyyah (628 AD), when Muhammad, being militarily weaker than the Quraysh, signed a ten-year peace treaty with the Meccans.

Once his forces grew stronger, Muhammad trumped up an excuse to claim the treaty had been broken, using this as justification to march on and conquer Mecca.

In classical Islamic jurisprudence, this episode underpins the doctrine that a truce [hudna] with unbelievers may be concluded only when Muslims are too weak to continue jihad successfully.

It must not exceed ten years, after which hostilities should resume if the balance of power allows.

Jurists like Ibn Taymiyyah and al-Mawardi explicitly codified this principle: truces are permissible only for tactical reasons and only temporarily, until conditions favour renewed jihad.

This means any peace treaty with non-Muslims is provisional and strategic, never permanent.


The invocation “Remember Hudaybiyyah” among Palestinian Arab leaders when speaking of ceasefires or peace treaties with Israel directly alludes to this very logic — outward accommodation masking a long-term strategic objective.

Lasting peace is impossible with deceitful people who harbor such deep-seated, longstanding religious-based hatred and enmity.

ENDS

Maureen Mehlman's avatar

Every time the Israelis have endeavored to negotiate, the islamist forces see it as a weakness and attack.

I have seen clips of children's programming, aimed at preschool children and its deplorable. It tells these toddlers Jews are evil, that they are animals, that they should not be left to live, all really horrible stuff to teach anyone, let alone babies.

What kind of sheer lunacy is this? My petsonal belief is that the leftists are aligned with islamists because they have a common enemy in Judeo-christian scripture, esp Yeshua.

I see Mohammed as an antichrist.

ROJO's avatar

The Palestinians created themselves for the purpose of destroying the Jewish nation. And if you don't see the left Islam alliance, you're in a coma.

Sarah's avatar

The Jews have nothing to do with it. Palestinian Rights? Unfortunately they don't seem to want to have rights. They prefer the destruction of Israel, sadly.

Nick's avatar

Mou is a pathetic islamist shill.

Jeffrey Kocher MD's avatar

@mou arresi: I don’t like it-uninformed opinions that is. Who invented and has been screaming the term Islamaphobia for years now? Divorced generally from any reference to „Palestinians“, another term cooked up by the western Leftists. And who facilitated the invasion of Europe by Muslims, with their rape culture-surely not Leftists. Who defends the fraud and ripping off of the US taxpayers by Somalis and other Muslims; who puts every obstacle possible to thwart these abuses from being prevented and prosecuted-surely it must not be Leftists.

Moodieonroody's avatar

Because of their leaders.

Rory Bowman's avatar

Why should the entire world be subject to Mohammed’s narcissistic injury? Shithead is jealous of Jews and feels entitled to rape and slaves. How “left” is that? 🤡

Michael Eriksson's avatar

Remind me which holy books advocate the raping of slaves?

Peter Hemmingson's avatar

As Palestinian Arab leaders have openly admitted, ‘Palestinian’ is a national identity created solely to delegitimise Israel. There never was a ‘Palestinian’ state, never a call for Palestinian nationalism before the State of Israel was created.

Palestinian Arab leaders openly admit their nationalism exists only to eliminate the Jewish state.

The entire anti-Israel movement is built upon a single lie: that in 1948, Israel ‘stole’ the land. Palestinian Arabs are simply resisting. But what if everything we’ve been told about this story is untrue?

What if the real history of 1948 shows not Muslim Arabs being forced out, but Jews, while seeking peace, having to fight for their lives against a genocidal impulse that willed their destruction long before Israel’s modern re-establishment?

In more than 2,000 years, there has never been a state called Palestine with Jerusalem as its capital. The term "Palestinian" is a modern political invention rather than historical reality.

Until the mid-20th century, “Palestine" was associated with Jews and their homeland.

After World War I, the British Mandate over “Palestine” was established by the League of Nations in 1920. This ended with the proclamation of the State of Israel in May 1948.

Under the Mandate, Jews, Muslim Arabs, Christian Arabs, and Druze all held British-issued Palestine Mandate passports, but Arabs were generally identified as Arabs, not Palestinians.

In the early to mid-20th Century, Jews used the term “Palestine” for various cultural and business activities. This included the Palestine Post (later the Jerusalem Post), the Palestine Symphony Orchestra, the Palestine Potash Company, and the Palestine Electric Company.

In 1937, Arab leader Auni Bey Abdul-Hadi proclaimed:

“Palestine is a term the Zionists invented … Our country for centuries was part of [the Ottoman Province of] Syria.”

Abdul-Hadi was clearly keen to distance the Palestinian Arabs from any Jewish connection that might be made.

After 1948, when Israel was established, the term "Palestine" fell out of use in reference to Israel. It was revived in 1964 with the formation of the PLO, the Palestine Liberation Organization, and began to be associated with Muslim Arabs, not Jews.

When the PLO was formed in 1964, the West Bank was part of Jordan. Gaza was part of Egypt. There was never at that time talk of ‘occupation’ or claims that Palestinian statehood was being trampled on. The PLO was created with the same objective Arab states had in 1948: to throw the Jews into the sea.

The PLO didn't demand the "liberation" of the Wesr Bank or Gaza. Its founding charter called only for the elimination of Israel.

If this conflict had always been about creating a Palestinian state, why wasn't Jordan's control of the West Bank or Egypt's control of Gaza considered occupation?

In 1977, Zuheir Mohsen, a member of the PLO executive committee, admitted:

“The Palestinian people do not exist. The creation of a Palestinian state is only a means for continuing our struggle against the state of Israel for our [Muslim] Arab unity … a separate Palestinian identity exists only for tactical reasons.”

Mohsen effectively concedes that those claiming to be “Palestinian” are in fact Muslim Arabs. They could go live in any Muslim Arab country, if other Arab leaders would agree to take them in.

Palestinian Arabs have never existed as a nation, an ethnicity, and certainly not as a country.

What exists is Palestinianism: a violent, masochistic, Arab-supremacist death cult whose defining purpose is not building a Palestinian state, but destroying the Jewish one.

A Palestinian is someone who subscribes to Palestinianism — the belief that Jewish sovereignty is an intolerable historical mistake and that Israel must eventually be eliminated.

That is why every peace process fails. You cannot negotiate Palestinianism into accepting Israel, because the rejection of Israel is Palestinianism.

You cannot separate Palestinianism from the fantasy of driving the Jews into the sea, because without that fantasy there is nothing left. There will be no peace until Palestinianism ceases to exist.

As noted earlier, the Palestinian Arabs never had a state. They were part of the Ottoman province of Syria until 1920, then under the British Mandate until 1948, along with everyone else in the region.

The Palestinian Arabs could have had their own country in 1948 had they’d wanted it. But instead of declaring their own State as the Jews did, they declared war on Israel.

Just hours after the historic UN decision to partition the former British Mandate of “Palestine” into a Jewish state and a state for the Palestinian Arabs, Israel was attacked by five Arab nations intent on destroying it and reclaiming the land in its entirety for Islam.

Despite Jewish leaders' assurances that non-combatants would be safe, many Palestinian Arabs fled to refugee camps in Lebanon, Jordan, and Gaza, expecting to return after a swift Arab victory.

Instead, Israel won, and Palestinian Arab leaders have kept their people trapped in squalid refugee camps and overcrowded shanty towns as a political weapon against Jewish Israel for over 75 years.

It benefits Palestinian Arab leaders for their people to remain refugees, because all that Western aid money goes to fund their ongoing war against the Jews.

Mou aressi's avatar

Why do you think Israel as a state has a right to exist?

Szuirad's avatar

…Because the knowledge of several things and thinking about Muslim’s world would produce cognitive dissonance (Cognitive dissonance describes the mental discomfort or psychological stress a person feels when holding two conflicting beliefs, values, or attitudes simultaneously, or when acting in a way that contradicts their beliefs.

To reduce this discomfort, people naturally try to resolve the tension—often by changing their beliefs, rationalizing their actions, or ignoring information that contradicts their view.)

TurquoiseThyme's avatar

Quite a few. We need to be gentle sometimes, I broke through the ignorance of one woman on Substack who had decided I was attacking Muslims when I suggested it was in America’s best interest to never allow a Muslim majority to occur here.

I didn’t tell her about all the things I know about crimes against woman and minorities that are the norm in many Islamic countries, because I knew she wouldn’t believe me because it would seem too extreme. So I asked her to find me a Muslim majority country where non-Muslim citizens didn’t have to pay some sort of fee for the privilege of not being Muslim.

She came back with Turkey sort of, but I could tell she now knew a lot more about Muslim majority countries and no longer thought I was a bigot who just hated people because they dressed funny.

I don’t, in any way, I was known for helping the Muslim girls with their homework in my graduate program, they asked me if I was Muslim once because they thought there must be a reason I was helping them. (I think English being a second language was why other students weren’t as helpful not them being Muslim. I wrote my Homework out in minute detail and could just point to a diagram or side note to walk them through the problem. Especially in graduate school mastery of written English while still having difficulty with spoken English is quite common.)

Neil M's avatar

we should suggest that they Google “at what point does tolerance get undermined by too much tolerance”

TurquoiseThyme's avatar

I really think she wouldn’t have done that, if you had asked. I set her on a quest to prove me wrong, she was seeking to teach me about my (imagined) blind bigotry and instead it sent her down the rabbit hole. She would not have googled that phrase because she would correctly interpret it as criticism of her.

Maureen Mehlman's avatar

when it demands compromise. once there it just keeps pushing.

Mou aressi's avatar

There is a not a single Muslim nation that taxes non-Muslims in any way. Please correct me if I’m wrong.

TurquoiseThyme's avatar

Did you have an example of one? Or were you saying there wasn’t? It’s unclear to me.

Mou aressi's avatar

From the information that I have there isn’t a single one that charges a tax to non-Muslims .is that true?

Mou aressi's avatar

There’s no left Islam alliance. The premise is wrong. The left is fighting for Palestinian rights.

why should Palestinian Arabs suffer for what the Germans did to the Jews?? That’s the fundamental issue and the question you cannot answer.

D33-L1TE's avatar

It was Jordan, Egypt, and other surrounding Islamic countries that told the Palestinians to flee their homes so they could wage war on the new state of Israel. Nobody had to leave. While I don’t agree with encroaching settlements in the West Bank, most Israelis aren’t inflicting violence except in self defense. Also,lots of Arab Muslims helped the Germans with their persecution of Jews. Jews are persecuted in every Muslim land, killed, or driven out.

Mou aressi's avatar

That’s not entirely accurate some may have fled due to what the Arab country said, but I’m sure they did not want to flee regardless of what the Arab countries told them to do. And secondly, regardless of that fact, why cannot they return today?? It was their homeland?? it’s collective punishment either way.

You’re not seriously going to argue that Arab Muslims had anything to do with the holocaust are you??

D33-L1TE's avatar

Palestine has been able to have a state of their own since the British Mandate. Quit being a perpetual victim and build something.

Sarah's avatar

Only when the Palestinians wake up and see how they've been used by the various Arab/Islamic Dictators over the decades - Dictators who don't give two hoots about their Rights - will they be free at last.

Mou aressi's avatar

Whether they want or can have a state of their own right now is not the issue. The issue and the question is why did Palestinian Arabs have to suffer because of what the Germans did to the Jews?? You cannot answer the question.

You cannot punish the son for the sins of the father. And the Arabs, who lived in Palestine in 1948 didn’t do anything to the European Jews. Germany did it. Remember?? So why do they have to pay by giving up any of their land?? You will not be able to answer.

Maureen Mehlman's avatar

Youre either stupid or horribly misinformed.

ROJO's avatar

The Arabs who later called themselves Palestinians, starting in 1964 after the KGB persuaded Arafat to start the PLO, are at fault along with the Arab states for their own suffering. They started attacking the Jews before the Holocaust. Their suffering has nothing to do with the Holocaust. Prior to the start of Zionism, there were few people at all living in the Holy Land. Arabs moved there from Syria, Egypt, and other nearby places, and until 1964, they wanted nothing to do with the name "Palestine."

Peter Hemmingson's avatar

Mou is nothing but a whiny little bitch like all of his ilk.

Maureen Mehlman's avatar

why should Israelis suffer near constant assault? Muslims claim the Israelis have no right to a homeland they've inhabited for over 5,000 years. this current fight has NOTHING to do with the holocaust. they've been under seige almost immediately after declaring the land the nation of Israel. there are 2 million Muslims who continue to live in Israel. They could leave if they feel unwelcome, but they don't. Why? Because they aren't unwelcome.

1948 Israel is established

9/14/1948

9/15/1948 Arab states begin attacking Israel. they are defeated. this war, the Arab/Israeli War ends in 1949 almost one full year later.

1956 -Suez Crisis (2nd Arab/Israel war)

1967- 6 Day War (3rd Arab/Israeli War

1973-Yom Kippur War

1982- Lebanon War

2006- Hezbollah War (Lebanon)

2026- Hamas War

The entire time, between official wars, Israel has been attacked with mortar rounds, terror strikes within. Israel isn't going anywhere. The ancestors of Jews have been in the Southern Levant for over 10,000 years. There has never been a time since prehistoric times through today that Jews have not been there. Even after the diaspora in the 1st Century, there remained a remnant. Rhe land of Judea has been under the control of a dozen different empires, from the Greek to the Ottoman. Through it all, the ancestors and the ppl who would become the Jewish ppl have been there.

Get over it.

Lauren9est19@gmail.com's avatar

And therein lies the issues. Maybe someone AI (perhaps they are still detached enough?) to design a VIDEO GAME to present these ideas accurately historically! But then again whose depiction of history?

Joel Hatcher's avatar

much of the left probably believes that once they get what they want with the help of islam, then they can cahnge islam into being good

much like women who believe they can fix a guy who is all kinds of stupid

Denise Molloy's avatar

🤣🤣🤣😪😪😪 the left are soft while the Islamist extremists are full of hate that will kill the left.

TurquoiseThyme's avatar

The left never studies history. The left has allied multiple times with Islam. Islam wins every time.

Polished Arrow's avatar

Along with any ban, I wish it would be explained why it is wise. Just one item is the tip of one of these icebergs. Prohibition of alcohol will be reinstituted. The Constitutional Amendment repealing will, itself, be repealed. All property, and all people, and all their children, will become Central Government property; ‘States’ as we know them, will end. Short list.

Henry Manning Harris's avatar

The left supports Islamic colonialism and their pseudo revolutionary movements becasue of one thing. It is in opposition to Christianity.

Ashley's avatar

What’s interesting is that leftist / communist Persians, who survived the brutal and deadly purge of the mullahs they helped bring to power, are fully aware and openly discuss the foolishness of having put their faith in the ayatollah and his followers prior to 1979.

Yet the modern leftists simply ignore that fairly recent history, and are doing exactly the same thing with their support of hamas, hizbollah, the iranian regime etc.

Like lambs to the slaughter…….

Talking Point IL's avatar

Despite that, when any of these sides achieves their goal- the other one who is present there geographically- suffers immensely.

• Look at the Uygurs in China,

• ⁠Or the expulsions of Tatars, Chechens and Ingush by Stalin,

• ⁠Or the dismantling of Islamic culture in Albania under Hoxha.

When leftists find themselves under an Islamic rule, it is not any better:

• A killing of 500 thousands to a million of communists in Indonesia in 1965-66,

• The imprisonment and execution of the communists who have helped to bring the Islamic revolution in Iran in 1979,

• The overthrow and persecution of the Afghan communists in 1979-92

And so on.

L Wayne Mathison's avatar

There is an ugly historical lesson here.

Parts of the radical left made a similar mistake with the Nazis. They became so consumed with defeating their preferred political enemies that they sometimes treated an authoritarian movement as a tactical partner or something they could manipulate.

Then the Nazis took power.

Communists, social democrats and trade unionists were among the first people arrested, their parties destroyed and many of their members thrown into concentration camps.

They discovered too late that sharing an enemy does not mean sharing values.

That is the danger in today's strange alliance between parts of the Western left and Islamist movements. You can oppose Western institutions, capitalism, Israel or whatever else you please, but don't fool yourself into believing an illiberal movement suddenly shares your commitment to women's equality, gay rights, secular government or free speech.

Authoritarians will gladly accept your support while it is useful.

The question is what happens when you are no longer useful.

Mark Armstrong's avatar

They love robbery and death and envy each other so they join as evil comrades: social communists Muslims . The devils social group on their road to hell literally.

Bita Bariran's avatar

We Iranians do not need theoretical arguments alone to arrive at the conclusion Danny Burmawi reaches; we have lived through this evil and repression. The “Red and Black Reaction” is not merely a historical expression for us; it is an experience for which we have paid the price through the destruction of our country, the suppression of freedoms, and the rupture of our path of development and civilization. Two different forces, united in their hostility toward the existing order and the modern world, arrived at a common point, and we all saw the result. The danger that threatens parts of Western civilization today is not unfamiliar to us; it has already come for Iran’s civilization and future.

His Imperial Majesty Aryamehr Mohammad Reza Shah Pahlavi wrote in “Answer to History” that his wish was for Iran to become a nation strong in industrial, military, and cultural terms for the next generation. And today, for us, the issue is the defense of Iran, the restoration of its glory, and the continuation of civilization. We want Iran to have a future again — to Make Iran Great Again (MIGA); an Iran that, instead of extending the legacy of reaction, continues along the path of modernization, freedom, security, prosperity, law, and progress. For us, saving Iran means reclaiming the future that the Red and Black Reaction took from us.

Lukas Bird's avatar

Excellent!!!

An even simpler rubric:

OPPRESSOR vs OPPRESSED

It feels like a general, global tidal wave that conflates across politics, economies, culture, civilizations.

West: Oppressor

Israel: Oppressor

Men: Oppressor

Whites: Oppressor

Capitalism: Oppressor

So, given the two ancient rivals are squaring off (Red Sox/Yankees, Lakers/Celtics, Eagles/Cowboys) for another round of winner take all - where the game may (or may not) - stay within the polite rules - Team Oppressed had better hope they can a totalized conflict. And the men they chased off don’t have the final say.

Giulio's avatar

"Stupidity is a worse enemy than evil."

Dietrich Bonhoeffer

Molly Scarlett 🌿🫒's avatar

Hm, this is an interesting idea but contains some pretty big generalisations, e.g. the idea that “the left” shows solidarity with Hamas. That would surely be an extreme minority, not “the left”. Solidarity with Palestinians ≠ solidarity with Hamas.

Will Freedom's avatar

Incorrect, because the vast majority of "Palestinians" support/love Hamas.

Molly Scarlett 🌿🫒's avatar

Well even if that's true it's not the left showing solidarity with Hamas. If you support someone does that mean you support all their beliefs? No.

"It's Phoenix Dark...Dirk."'s avatar

How do they show support? Answer: by chanting from the river to the sea. Do you know what that means? If, on the other hand, what you mean is support in terms of providing food, water, and liberation from Hamas, well, Israel is doing all that much better than anyone on the left.

Molly Scarlett 🌿🫒's avatar

You truly must have a profound form of cognitive dissonance to believe that. That is a straw man fallacy, you are clearly arguing in bad faith.

Will Freedom's avatar

LOL Hamas doesn't HAVE any other beliefs. Their only cause is killing Jews and trying to wipe Israel off the map. And a sideline in subjugating women, stealing aid to sell for weapons, and stoning gays and rape victims - wups, I mean moral turpitudes and adulteresses.

The Real Jane Doe's avatar

This is cope. There is no separating so-called Palestinians from Islamism, be it Hamas or Hezbollah.

Further - there is shockingly little care and concern from western leftists about the abuse of Uyghur Muslims in China or minority Christians in Africa, both oppressed and slaughtered, raped and imprisoned.

This indicates one or possibly two things: the left is either concerned with Israel and shares Islamist anti-Western priors or they're just too dumb to look at something outside of their social media feed. Possibly both.

Joseph's avatar

Thats because most Islamic movements are sponsored by Qatar, qatar also funds pro Palestine movements, these funds go to leftist organisations, these leftist organisations are now obliged to talk about Palestine only

Joseph's avatar

Thats because most Islamic movements are sponsored by Qatar, qatar also funds pro Palestine movements, these funds go to leftist organisations, these leftist organisations are now obliged to talk about Palestine only

Don beech's avatar

OK Molly, but being an ideological/moral position, the left has no compulsion to self criticism. Just like Islam, the left is erected on HETERONOMY...but whereas in Islam truth is GIVEN by Allah, on the left, truth is GIVEN by History objectified in time, space and the forces of production. Its why the final battle will be between the mad mullahs and the mad leftists.

Kip 🇺🇸🇮🇱🟦's avatar

You're either hopelessly ignorant or just a liar.

Molly Scarlett 🌿🫒's avatar

That's an enlightening argument 😂

WSR1689's avatar

With intersectionality the more categories of oppression that you fit in wins.

So being an African American woman gets a lower oppression score and is a low card. Compared to a Black hispanic transgender lesbian that has gone through surgery, is also an illegal alien and was born in subSaharan Africa.

TurquoiseThyme's avatar

Thank you for this great article, I had not considered how the left and liberals view the world to its logical conclusion.

I absolutely think the underlying philosophy of a culture creates that culture.

Mary Grande's avatar

What a great treatise! It is exactly what I believe. There is no real hope for the west to overcome the ignorance and self flagellation or punishment that much of the left has adopted. But the west can refuse to accept any more immigrants or refugees from these parts of the world that have proven incompatible or unable to control their own adherents.